Dishwashers vs. Handwashing: Which Cleans Better, Saves More, and Is the Right Choice for You?

ByNathan Gorman

Both dishwashers and handwashing have their pros and cons, but when it comes to efficiency, cleanliness, and saving resources, which method really stands out? Let’s break down the advantages and disadvantages of each and get to the bottom of the dishwashers vs. handwashing debate.

1. Water Consumption: A Clear Winner?

dishwasher

When it comes to water usage, dishwashers take the lead—hands down.

  • Dishwashers: A standard dishwasher uses between 3-4 gallons of water per cycle. Some eco-friendly models, like Energy Star-certified dishwashers, use as little as 3.5 gallons per load. These modern appliances are designed to recycle water during the cycle, making them far more efficient than handwashing.
  • Handwashing: This method can use up to 27 gallons of water per session. That’s around 15 gallons every five minutes if the tap is running constantly. If you’re conscientious about water conservation, this might not be the best option unless you’re following strict water-saving techniques like filling a basin and not running the water continuously.

Verdict: Dishwashers win this round, especially if you’re looking to conserve water.

2. Cleaning Power: Which Method is More Sanitary?

clean dishes

Cleaning isn’t just about getting dishes to look clean—it’s about eliminating bacteria and ensuring that your family stays healthy.

  • Dishwashers: Most dishwashers heat water to over 140°F, a temperature high enough to kill harmful bacteria. Newer models have sanitizing cycles that can raise the temperature even higher, ensuring that dishes come out bacteria-free.
  • Handwashing: Even the hottest water from your faucet usually won’t exceed 120°F, which may not be hot enough to kill bacteria effectively. Moreover, the sponges or cloths you use to scrub dishes can harbor bacteria, making your dishes less sanitary than they seem.

Verdict: Dishwashers take the lead in terms of cleanliness and sanitation.

3. Time Investment: Which Saves You Time?

handwashing

Time is precious, especially when you have a family to care for or a job to attend to. Let’s see which method saves more of it.

  • Dishwashers: While a typical dishwasher cycle can last between 1.5 to 4 hours, you’re not actively involved. You load it, press start, and walk away. Some models even have a quick-wash option for less dirty dishes, making them even more convenient.
  • Handwashing: On average, it takes about 15 seconds to wash a dish. For a full load that could go into a dishwasher (about 10-12 place settings), you’ll spend roughly 30 minutes scrubbing and rinsing. You’re involved every step of the way.

Verdict: Dishwashers win in terms of active time spent, allowing you to multitask or relax while your dishes get cleaned.

4. Resource Cost: Which is Easier on Your Wallet?

money

Let’s talk dollars and cents—because, after all, both time and resources cost money.

  • Dishwashers: A dishwasher costs more upfront (ranging from $400 to $2,000, depending on the model). However, when it comes to operating costs, dishwashers tend to be more economical. Energy Star dishwashers, for instance, can save you up to $40 per year in utility costs. Over its lifetime, a dishwasher can save you about 4,000 gallons of water.
  • Handwashing: It might seem like handwashing is cheaper, but in reality, the amount of water you use can increase your water bill significantly—especially if you’re washing large loads regularly. Plus, if you’re using hot water, that can add up to higher energy bills too.

Verdict: Over time, a dishwasher is more cost-effective, especially if you factor in water and energy savings.

Other Factors to Consider

While water, cleanliness, time, and cost are the primary concerns, there are a few other things worth thinking about:

  • Environmental Impact: Using a dishwasher is generally more eco-friendly if you run full loads and avoid pre-rinsing your dishes. Handwashing uses significantly more water and energy in comparison.
  • Convenience: While dishwashers win on time and efficiency, not all items are dishwasher safe. Fragile glassware, non-stick pans, wooden utensils, and certain plastics should be washed by hand to avoid damage.
  • Space: If you don’t have space for a dishwasher or can’t afford one, handwashing might be your only option. But for larger households with plenty of dishes, a dishwasher is almost a necessity.

When to Handwash Instead of Using a Dishwasher

handwashing

Despite all the benefits of dishwashers, there are times when handwashing is your best bet:

  • Fragile or Special Items: Delicate items like crystal, fine china, and certain cookware can get damaged in a dishwasher. Handwashing is the safest option for these.
  • Small Loads: If you only have a couple of dishes to wash, handwashing can be more convenient than waiting to run a full load in the dishwasher.
  • Introducing Some Good Bacteria: Believe it or not, some studies show that growing up in super-sanitized environments can increase allergies. Handwashing may introduce harmless bacteria that help build a stronger immune system in young kids.

FAQs: Dishwashers vs. Handwashing

Q1: Is it cheaper to handwash or use a dishwasher?
While handwashing seems cheaper, dishwashers use less water and energy, making them more economical over time—especially if you have an Energy Star-rated model.

Q2: Do dishwashers really sanitize dishes?
Yes, most dishwashers heat water to 140°F or higher, which is hot enough to kill harmful bacteria.

Q3: What items should I never put in the dishwasher?
Avoid putting wooden utensils, cast iron pans, non-stick pots, and fragile glassware in the dishwasher, as the high heat can damage these items.

Q4: Can handwashing really waste that much water?
Yes! Washing dishes under a running faucet can use up to 27 gallons of water, while dishwashers only use 3-4 gallons per cycle.

Wrapping It Up: Dishwashers vs. Handwashing

In the debate between dishwashers vs. handwashing, dishwashers come out on top in almost every category—water and energy savings, cleaning power, and time efficiency. Handwashing is still necessary for certain items, but for the average household, a dishwasher is the smarter, more eco-friendly choice.

At the end of the day, it’s about balancing convenience, cost, and what works best for your household.

Call 1-Tom-Plumber 

Don’t hesitate to contact us here or call us at 1-Tom-Plumber (1-866-758-6237) if you need any plumbing, drain cleaning, water damage, or excavation service. 1-Tom-Plumber’s certified team of plumbers and drain technicians respond immediately to any emergency plumbing, drain cleaning, or water damage problem. We also handle the excavation of underground water lines and sewer main lines. Our immediate-response team is available every day and night of the year, even on holidays.

Similar Posts